Geothermal heat pumps offer an attractive alternative to traditional heating and cooling systems, but implementation of these systems can be complex, so facility operators considering them should take extra time with capital planning, according to Mike Richter, president of Brightcore Energy.
Thanks to tax credit incentives that avoided accelerated phase-outs in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, geothermal systems remain largely cost-competitive to traditional systems, said Richter in an interview. Over the long term, these systems, which don’t face a tax-credit phase-out until 2034, can significantly cut energy costs and offer reliability at a time when oil and gas prices remain sky-high, he said.
Similar to electric vehicles — which have been around for years but only recently made the strides in performance that make them competitive against traditional cars and trucks — geothermal heating and cooling systems are now capable of providing excellent service to building occupants, according to Richter.
“They’re cleaner, they’re quieter within your building [and] they’re quieter for your neighbors,” said Richter, whose company installs geothermal and other renewable energy systems like solar as well as energy-efficiency solutions. In addition, they are floodproof and fireproof, offering longevity and resiliency, he said.
“But if you don’t have familiarity with them, or you’ve done no upfront consideration of them, when it’s time to replace [your system], it’s pretty hard to just decide what [you’re] going to do,” he said. “You have a lot of work in front of you. I can’t tell you that it’s going to work for your building until I do some evaluation, which takes time.”
Still, the timeline required to evaluate geothermal is shrinking as people begin to understand these systems, according to Richter. Considering the large financial lift that operators can get from the tax credits, economic concerns with the systems are starting ease, he said.
“It’s going to cost about the same as putting in conventional [systems]. It’s going to last longer. It’s going to be cheaper to operate,” Richter said. “Where’s the hurdle? That might be the design part.”
Because of this challenge, and the fact that many facilities teams do not have the information or the technical expertise to evaluate and implement these solutions, it’s important who you partner with, he said.
“Good people will do the evaluation, [and] if it doesn’t look like it’s going to be a financial winner in particular, they should tell you that, and you go on to the next option,” he said.
There is still a greater need for education in the field of geothermal as well.
“Facilities managers say, ‘Look, we’d love to do geothermal, but we’re on top of bedrock. We can’t do it.’ But that’s precisely where you can do it. The thermal qualities are great. There’s just a need for people to have more information,” he said. “We can pretty much do this anywhere.”
However, Richter says that in spots where geothermal isn’t economically viable, operators shouldn’t try to force it.
There are enough proven technologies out there today that instead of looking for the next great invention that can solve every problem, operators should be considering all options and deciding what works best for their situation, Richter said.
“There’s enormous potential to use market-proven technologies, off-the-shelf technologies. We just need to ask the questions upfront before there’s a crisis moment, so we can start deploying these things at scale,” he said.