Dive Brief:
- A large number of consumer electronics — entertainment devices, gaming consoles and cars — that connect to building operational networks are vulnerable to cyber threats and expose industrial and healthcare facilities to attack, according to a report released Tuesday by cybersecurity firm Claroty.
- A study of more than 45 million devices found 65,000 non-essential consumer devices connected to sensitive operations networks, putting them directly alongside mission-critical industrial and medical equipment, per the report.
- While these devices may appear harmless, they can become an entry point for attackers when their shared connection to network infrastructure exposes industrial control systems, building management systems and medical devices, Claroty says.
Dive Insight:
Industrial networks rely on programmable logic controllers, or PLCs, to communicate with sensors, actuators and other smart instruments to ensure production lines and other critical systems remain reliable and available. PLCs also sync with human-machine interfaces and supervisory control and data acquisition systems to connect humans to physical processes as well as other PLCs to coordinate production line actions, edge gateways to send field data and enterprise systems for inventory tracking and scheduling, Claroty says in its report.
“Nowhere in that chain should there also be a Nintendo Switch or a Tesla Model 3,” the cybersecurity firm says. “Time after time we discovered these types of assets right alongside PLCs, patient monitors, and other devices on company networks.”
The company says that consumer devices are rarely designed to meet the security, reliability and lifecycle requirements of operational environments. Many also have insecure communications or reach out to the public internet to a cloud service outside a factory or hospital’s control, per the report.
“Most organizations will not have visibility into these rogue third parties’ security posture and the risks they may introduce to production and medical networks,” Claroty says. “The fundamental problem is these devices introduce unmanaged assets, unexpected communications, and potential vulnerabilities into an environment where a compromise can have physical consequences.”
The company pointed to recent cyber attacks on supermarkets in Europe, where attackers accessed networks through unsecured internet-facing assets. In that event, attackers were able to turn on defrost mode, resulting in rising temperatures that caused millions of dollars in food damage.
“Once a device is compromised, its position on the network becomes important,” Claroty says.
The report named three types of consumer devices that are especially vulnerable: gaming consoles, smart home and entertainment devices and connected vehicles.
Claroty found 95% of the 14,624 gaming consoles it discovered at hospitals were connected to production networks instead of guest or IoT networks or virtual local area networks, or VLANs, with 4.7% categorized as high risk. Almost 90% of the 963 gaming consoles in industrial environments were connected to these networks, with 3.1% categorized as high risk.
“In industrial and commercial applications, the presence of gaming systems is considerably smaller, but with zero viable business use, their presence is often more troubling,” Claroty says.
Meanwhile, Roku streaming sticks, smart watches and Sonos media players were the most common consumer IoT entertainment devices found in these environments, per the report.
“Our research uncovered thousands of consumer IoT devices operating on production OT networks — none of which serve legitimate business cases in critical infrastructure settings,” the company said.
Connected vehicles also pose a threat. They require Wi-Fi connectivity for software updates and patches, which leads employees to connect personal vehicles to corporate networks. Teslas were the most common manufacturer of vehicle components found connected to industrial or healthcare networks, followed by Ford, Texas Instruments, Honda and Hyundai.
The report noted that six critical vulnerabilities were discovered on Tesla Model 3s, including remote code execution and buffer overflow vulnerabilities that can provide an entry point into networks. The company found 121 security issues linked to Ford F-150 trucks. Almost none of the vehicles discovered were properly isolated onto guest networks, Claroty says.
The company underscored that each of these devices connected to a production network represents expanded attack surface, a potential pivot point for lateral movement into a system and a blind spot in security monitoring.
"Finding consumer technology like Apple Watches and Nintendo Switches residing on the same networks as OT and medical equipment points directly to ongoing deficiencies in network governance and segmentation within operational settings," Sean Tufts, field chief technology officer at Claroty, said in a statement. "Addressing this issue does not mean stripping smart TVs from conference rooms or banning XBOX consoles from hospitals; it requires closing off unnecessary pathways for malicious actors from causing intolerable disruptions and negatively impacting businesses across industries."
Claroty recommends that organizations secure their critical infrastructure by implementing strict network segmentation — separating guest, IoT and production networks with enforced policies; performing continuous asset discovery to maintain real-time visibility into all connected devices; preventing unauthorized devices from accessing production networks; and replacing legacy systems and redesigning network architectures.
“Cybersecurity as a whole is IT with good fundamentals,” Tufts told Facilities Dive in an interview. “It’s nothing more simple than that. It’s having the time and energy to get the thing done correctly, rather than done to a working standard.”
Claroty also suggests organizations centralize security policy and establish governance frameworks.
“When gaming consoles, smart watches, and personal vehicles no longer share networks with critical operational technology, we will have achieved much of the segmentation necessary to protect our most vital systems,” Claroty says. “Until then, the chaos is just one misconfigured VLAN away.”